Montgomery County, Maryland, Proud Sanctuary Jurisdiction, Gets What It Deserves: The Biggest Tax Hike in Seven Years As Student Achievement Wanes

Businessman Piggy Bank SurpriseWhen Montgomery County, Maryland, Council President Nancy Floreen appeared on WMAL radio in Washington, D.C. to explain the county’s new budget, which hikes taxes 8.7 percent, the highest spike in seven years, she crowed about how the money would help the schools. “Classrooms are crowded,” she said. “We have a lot of teacher issues.”

Asked about the impact of illegal immigration on this population in the schools, she became flustered and claimed that the figures were unavailable to her at the time, implying that the numbers are out there. School and county officials, however, said that they do not track the figure.

Montgomery County schools are dealing with the same issues as other magnets for illegal immigration: costs are rising but performance by students in the English for Speakers of Other Languages (ESOL) program is poor.

With teachers being asked to do more in Montgomery County, the new budget could have a negative effect on morale since the school system plans to negate a negotiated eight percent raise and only offer 4.5 percent, a move allowed by state law.

The growth of ESOL programs around the country is stark and estimates vary on what percentage of these students are illegal immigrants or the offspring of illegal immigrants. Many states face challenges recruiting teachers and by 2018, Maryland is projected to require an additional 492 certified ESOL instructors at a cost of $31.2 million.

In Montgomery County, the ESOL program grew from 15,931 students in 2009-2010 to 22,600 in 2016-2017, an increase of 42 percent. Around 15 percent of all students are in the ESOL program and the county will spend $412 million educating them in 2016-2017, about $142 million and 53 percent more than in 2010. Overall, the school budget rose from $2 billion in 2010 to $2.5 billion in 2016-2017.

Even with all this money, there is little to show for it because like their counterparts across the country, progress is slow for ESOL students in Montgomery County. Educators have devised four performance indicators: Below Basic, Basic, Proficient and Advanced. Only 40 percent of third grade ESOL students scored Proficient or above in math, while 53 percent hit the mark in reading.

The numbers plummet from there with just 27 percent of eleventh graders and 30 percent of ESOL seniors reaching proficiency in English. Beyond their lack of progress in English, ESOL students in Montgomery County also have trouble with math. Just a third of county fifth graders studying ESOL reached proficiency and the latest eighth grade results are even worse: 21.5 percent.

One dirty little secret in Montgomery County is that the schools are largely segregated, according to a 2014 report by the county Office of Legislative Oversight. Schools on the eastern side of the county lag behind those on the upscale west side. Wealthy residents are paying more to maintain this system, but their children are generally unaffected by the impact of overcrowding and limited resources. Welcoming unprepared students into the public schools and then failing to properly educate them serves no one’s interest, including the illegal alien students themselves.


And, like many other districts nationwide, Montgomery school officials excluded a large proportion of ESOL and learning-disabled students from taking standardized tests to inflate the countywide scores, a scandal that blipped across the radar and into oblivion in 2013. This is happening all across the country: in 2012, for example, El Paso’s school superintendent received a 42-month federal prison sentence for the very same transgression.

When the federal government allows people to walk across the border, then pushes them into schools ill-equipped to handle the influx, it amounts to arguably the biggest unfunded mandate that the federal government has ever dumped onto the states.

But Maryland and Montgomery County have partially brought this on themselves, since the state issues driver’s licenses to illegal immigrants and Montgomery County proudly touts its illegal alien sanctuary policy, which creates a welcoming atmosphere and prevents local officials from cooperating with federal immigration officials.

This policy hamstrings municipalities within the jurisdiction that want to stem the flow of illegal aliens and try to get a handle on rising taxes. Serving the growing ESOL population in Montgomery County and across the United States will require sustained funding that will leave school districts scrambling to balance their budgets without cutting services to students. The only thing to show for it so far is mediocrity.

About Author


Content written by Federation for American Immigration Reform staff.


  1. avatar

    Thank Martin O, and the dumbocratics that are running this state into the ground, for this insanity.

  2. avatar

    Hillary was on MSNBC this afternoon. She said that she would begin working on “reform leading to full citizenship” immediately and it would be one of her “most important priorities”. Good thing she has things in order, huh?

    She also mirrored the president, who attacked Trump today. He claimed Trump doesn’t “understand our system” and that there are “no religious tests” in this country, meaning we can’t use religion to exclude people. Uh wrong. That applies to OUR citizens. Another made up “right” existing solely in his mind. The constitution gives no one from any country or group a right to enter here. WE decide, not them.

    In fact, we have a list of countries whose citizens must undergo more scrutiny [or at least are SUPPOSED to] before they are allowed to visit here. [Mostly Muslim countries but let’s pretend otherwise] The 9/11 Commission noted that many of the hijackers should not have even been allowed in, because they were single young men with no jobs and no family ties here and from countries of, shall we say, “special concern”.

    And there seems to be collective amnesia over the fact that this president attended a church for 20 years where the preacher delivered anti American anti white rhetoric, including saying that 9/11 was “the chickens coming home to roost”. But he claimed never to have heard any of that.