What Kind Of Democratic Party Will this Week’s Debates Showcase?



Americans were given a glimpse of far out of the mainstream many Democratic politicians have drifted when all ten candidates on the podium during last month’s first debate raised an affirmative hand to the question of whether their health insurance plan would cover illegal aliens. It is a position shared by a majority of the 20-plus Democratic presidential candidates, but one which risks alienating conservative Democrats, Independents and even Hispanic voters.

“I think there has to be some moderation. I disagree with the candidates’ positions about providing health care to undocumented immigrants, when you have Americans who don’t have health care,” said Domingo Garcia, president of the League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC), following the June Democratic presidential primary debate, who surmised their answer “wasn’t thought through.”

Garcia is not the only one who disagrees.

The embrace of health care coverage may have been popular within the debate hall, but a CNN survey taken several weeks later found 59 percent of Americans opposed the idea. In a mid-July NPR/PBS Newshour/Marist College poll, the opposition was even higher – and not just among Republicans.

Asked whether “a national health insurance program available” to illegal aliens is a good or a bad idea, 66 percent of all Democrats said it is a good idea, while 32 percent disagree. But when broken down along ideological identification, moderate Democrats were more inclined to voice opposition (47 percent) than support (43 percent) and even more Independent voters (67 to 27 percent) rejected the idea.

Of the handful of candidates who have released immigration plans, it does not appear they have thought beyond the Democratic primaries and caucuses. In her plan, Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren calls for the near-abolition of ICE ; admitting six to eight times more refugees than Trump has to date; ending private detention centers; and decriminalizing illegal immigration.

Many of those same policies, are backed by Sen. Kamala Harris of California with one notable exception – decriminalization of illegal immigration. Despite voicing support for it during the first debate, Harris flipped her stance last week.

“That is not correct, I’m not in favor of decriminalizing or not having consequence for, let me be very clear, we have to have a secure border, but I am in favor of saying that we’re not going to treat people who are undocumented cross the border as criminals, that is correct, that is correct,” Harris said during an appearance last Friday on The View.

She then clarified: “I would not make it a crime punishable by jail. It should be a civil enforcement issue but not a criminal enforcement issue.”

Perhaps Harris’ campaign staff took note of the findings of the PBS/NPR/Marist poll that found 68 percent of Independents and 58 percent of so-called moderate Democrats who think that is a bad idea.

For months Democrats have been able to slide with canned comments about “comprehensive immigration reform” and criticisms of the President Trump’s rhetoric without having to come up with real solutions or policy specifics.

As Tara Golshan of the liberal Vox writes, “Still, immigration remains one of the most contentious policy issues in the United States. And Democrats’ plans so far aren’t addressing the most divisive issues, including whom to deport and whom to let in.”

So far the Democrats who have addressed those divisive issues have taken positions at odds with moderates in their party and average Americans. Will any of that change during two days of televised debates on CNN? Tune in.

About Author

avatar

Jennifer joined FAIR as Web Content Writer in 2017 and brings to the role extensive communications and media background. She began her career as a policy research analyst on multiple national and state political campaigns before entering journalism. In addition to spending over a decade writing for several broadcast and print news outlets, Jennifer directed communications strategy for a member of Congress and a military nonprofit.

2 Comments

  1. Pingback: What Kind Of Democratic Party Will this Week’s Debates Showcase? – ukraineng

  2. avatar

    Harris is lying when she says “let me be very clear, we have to have a secure border”. It the same soft soap all the Democrats say, and then do everything to undermine a secure border. Because when she says she wants crossing the border illegally to be “a civil enforcement issue” she means nothing more serious than a parking ticket with a small fine. She’s already waffled on the elimination of private healthcare plans, saying she “misunderstood” the question at the debate. She’s like every other Democrat. No detentions, no deportations, and amnesty for all illegals is open borders. That’s why she and the others go on programs like the View because they know they will get nothing but softball questions. And that’s why the Democrats refuse to hold any of their debates on FOX. They will get asked to explain their positions.

    A little noticed aspect of the Trump/Cummings dustup is that it began with Cummings bashing border patrol officials for the supposed mistreatment of illegals. And Trump noted people like Cummings need to worry about their own constituents. Why do black Americans continue to support a party that falls all over itself to cater to illegals. Bernie Sanders previously called Baltimore a “third world” city in parts. As far as rats, Los Angeles is so overrun with them that there is a typhus outbreak. But let’s ignore those problems because we have to lavish assistance on people who crossed the border yesterday.