Does the Public Charge Rule Deny Citizenship?

On August 12th, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) filed the final version of the Inadmissibility on Public Charge Grounds rule. Acting head of USCIS Ken Cuccinelli held a press conference announcing the rule, emphasizing that generations of immigrants have pursued their dreams and successfully naturalized without requiring government assistance and needs-based welfare.

Following the announcement, multiple media outlets and activist groups slammed the public charge rule as a “cruel new step.” One activist claimed that the rule advances the idea that “if you are brown and you are an immigrant, you are not welcome here.” The Washington Post ran a story making the blanket claim that the rule denies citizenship.

That assertion is simply incorrect. The public charge rule will prevent some nonimmigrant visa holders from adjusting their status to a lawful permanent resident (green card) if they are likely to require significant government assistance in the future. That is not the same as denying citizenship.

Further, this is not some novel concept, it began in the 19th century. The new rule only provides further guidance on how the existing law should be applied to people likely to become dependent on entitlements in the future. Entitlement spending already makes up 70% of total government spending and is pushing us to the brink of financial disaster – any effort to reduce that spending is a step in the right direction.

The public charge rule does not deny citizenship to those who already have green cards and hope to naturalize – i.e. become citizens. The policy will not apply retroactively to people who used past benefits, and also does not apply to family members of U.S. citizens. It does not affect recipients of refugee and asylum seeking naturalization.

And the hypocrisy surrounding this issue is awe inspiring. Open borders activists first told us that immigrants actually use very little welfare and few public services. Now, they are telling us that preventing public charges from pursuing green cards will affect hundreds of thousands of immigrants who need benefits. Which is it? It’s not possible for both assertions to be correct at the same time.

The howling critics of the President refuse to admit that this is actually a straight-forward and common-sense proposal. Since the 19th century, American policy has dictated that immigrants should attempt to be self-reliant. The public charge rule promotes the fundamental American principle of self-sufficiency, enforces long-standing law, and protects American taxpayers from runaway entitlements spending.

About Author



  1. avatar

    So anchor babies can now help their parents if they cant be self sufficent? yet another reason why we need to clarify birthright citizenship.

  2. avatar
    Estelle Redden on

    I can’t see that it denies any citizen of the world to become an American citizen, if they meet our criteria, and we must be diligent about our laws here. If we don’t support and enforce our laws, we will find ourselves unable to assist our naturally born Americans, and there fore we would soon become the poorest country on planet Earth. I support this president without hesitation because I know in my heart. President Trump loves our country and all of her people!

    • avatar

      You are right on your opinion and the ones that are opposing to the enforcenent of the law that has existed for years are the immigration lawyers that charge thousand of dollars to process simple forms of immigration . Also the children born in the USA are the ones that use the welfare and they are not applying for legal status and the illegal parents cannot receive aid anyway so i don’t see how it will affect the people aplying for a legal status.

  3. avatar

    If You Don’t Speak English or Your Kids Don’t Speak English

    And you came to America [likely illegally?], tell me why the tax payer should make that a public school cost to teach your family English? There is no common sense answer except eliminate this “mooch” foreign invader cost destroying our public schools.

    We need math and science teaches with Bachelors of Science credentials at our public schools again, not NWO green card OVERPOPULATION/dumbification of America…

  4. Pingback: Does the Public Charge Rule Deny Citizenship? – The Importance of Business